Clouds gather over Wolsztyn services

by

Wolsztyn_clouds

Ol49-69 at Wolsztyn Station on a service train in August 2012. Photo BTWT.

The idea always carried some risk – setting up a separate body to run Wolsztyn Shed – the new body to be owned by PKP Cargo and the local authorities. Neither have a strong reputation for marketing or a passion for steam, two of the criteria that we would be looking for in any organisation to run the steam depot through the new millenium.

At least under the original scheme (see, BTWT 19.03.2010), the new company was going to be well capitalised – PKP’s Cargo’s steam locomotives and the shed was going to be valued at 5 million PLN and a similar amount in hard cash was going to be brought in by the Wielkopolska provincial government. Historic locomotives were going to be restored to running order and Wolsztyn was going to become a world class tourist attraction.

But it was not to be, negotiations with PKP Cargo dragged on. How many Cargo officials were trying for a place on the board of the new company as a sinecure to ends their days in profitable retirement? Meanwhile local government elections were held and the main proponent of the project in the Wielkopolska Urzad Marszalkowski (Chief Executive’s office) had moved on to pastures new…  .

By September 2011, PKP Cargo’s main board had passed the necessary resolutions, but the U.M. was having distinctly cold feet. The scheme returned to the drawing board. Now it has returned in a new guise, but with the capitalisation very much reduced. Instead of 10 million PLN, the new company will start operations with a capital of 1 million.

PKP’s contribution will be 500,000 PLN (in the form of a transfer of title of the steam locomotives) and the 3 local authorities (the Wielkopolska, provisional government, the Wolsztyn District Council and the Wolsztyn Town Council) will contribute 170,000 PLN each.

Not only is the cash component ludicrously small, but presumably this time round the title to the property is being excluded from the deal and the new organisation will be hobbled from the start by having to pay a commercial rent for the land and buildings occupied by the shed.

wolsztyn_slide_1

Slide showing income from hauling scheduled steam services ending in 2017. Slide UMWW.

Thanks to some accounting magic running the shed under the new regime is going to be profitable! The ‘expensive’ scheduled steam services will be phased out by 2017 (see graph) and the new organisation will concentrate on running ‘profitable’ steam specials for tourists. Now Jerzy Kriger’s letter (see BTWT 23.01.2013) can be understood in a wider context. The loss of weekend services is just the beginning of the run down of steam-hauled passenger services leading to their complete elimination by 2017.

Whoever wrote this plan clearly has no understanding that what makes Wolsztyn different is that it is the running depot for the world’s only main line regular steam-hauled passenger service that is NOT based on ‘steam specials’.

Without its scheduled steam passenger trains Wolsztyn become another historic steam depot and falls from its spot at the top – as the world’s only steam depot servicing locos running regular passenger trains – to ‘just another steam centre’.

The rescue plan as drawn up by the UMWW (Wielkopolska province Chief Executive’s office) shows only three locomotives being maintained in running order: Pt47-65, Ol49-59 and Ol49-69 – hardly a world class attraction.

What is more Poland is littered with remains of similar schemes that have failed. The steam sheds at Elk and Koscierzyna were going to make a profit running steam specials. Chabowka’s once popular public steam specials now only run at the time of Parowozjazda – its annual steam gala.

Without  PKP PLK, Poland’s infrastructure manager, all such schemes are doomed to failure – PKP’s track access charges are amongst the highest in Europe and steam-hauled specials enjoy no special rates.

Tr5-65-1000720

Tr5-65 awaiting overhaul at Leszno. The Orenstein & Koppel built ex Prussian railways 2-8-0 is absolutely unique, but will it ever steam again? Photo BTWT.

Sources:

Advertisements

4 Responses to “Clouds gather over Wolsztyn services”

  1. Rik Degruyter Says:

    In Belgium the rate for running steam trains on the national network was limited two years ago to only 1 euro/km.

  2. Gavin Whitelaw Says:

    That 1E/Km is not going to happen in Poland.

    Too many people wanting a slice of the pie. Corruption and the perception that steam is old fashioned and out of place will, as I though it would, see the end of regular steam in Poland. They DO NOT REALISE WHAT THEY HAVE!!! They are making ALL the same mistakes as Britain did in the 1960s and 70s and they will not take on board any lessons they can learn from the tourist railways in Britain.

    Too much is wrong with the railways in Poland for Wolsztyn to recover. The weekend railcars were, as I thought earlier, the thin end of the wedge.

    It COULD be made to work if Wolsztyn only realised that the regular steam is ALL that brings tourists to Wolsztyn, if it was marketed at all it would bring in more tourists. The Poles are hopeless at marketing – they still largely assume that the state will provide, while the politicians are creaming off the money at the top.

    Given all the information (available to the people who could make a difference) that they are ignoring, and that is info from Poland, where similar cases as Elk and Chabowka have largely failed financially AND from Britain where tourist railways flourish, they obviously do not wish to see steam continue.

    That is a pity. But when you confront people with all the facts, case studies that work and they STILL ignore all the best practice then what more can you do.

    The politicians obviously see the steam operation as an affront to the brave new Poland of the 21st Century. They are blinkered and cannot see that it is something that will bring tourists in if properly advertised and marketed, and it WILL need money spent on it. There is a lot wrong with the rail infrastructure in Poland and I don’t think that ANY of the answers they are coming up with are going to work.

  3. John Says:

    One of the advantages Poland has for running steam is the significant amount of infrastructure still in place to support it. Lack of suitable infrastructure has been one of the key factors that has seen the cessation of Plandampf in Germany.

    Many in Poland do understand what they have, but is seems few of these Poles are in positions of influence. Unfortunately the political and economic history of Poland is real and Poles may just want to be able to forget the past.

    I do feel sorry for the people of Wolsztyn who will ultimately suffer from the loss of tourist money in their town…

  4. Lukas Says:

    Video z parady w Wolsztynie 2013:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s